Celebrating a baptism is a deeply meaningful event, often shared with close family and friends. Whether you're looking for a cozy brunch setting, a waterfront view, or a spacious hall to accommodate your loved ones, Long Island offers a variety of venues to suit every taste and budget. Here’s a curated list of some of the best places to host a baptism party across Nassau and Suffolk counties.

1. The Fox Hollow – Woodbury, NY


Nestled in the heart of Nassau County, The Fox Hollow offers elegant ballrooms, beautifully manicured gardens, and award-winning catering. Ideal for both intimate gatherings and larger celebrations, their staff goes above and beyond to ensure your event is special.


  • Why it’s great: Upscale ambiance, all-inclusive packages, and exceptional service.
A couple embraces lovingly on a dirt path beside tall ornamental grasses on an overcast afternoon.

2. Captain Bill’s – Bay Shore, NY


If you’re looking for a stunning waterfront venue, Captain Bill’s delivers. Located right on the Great South Bay, this venue combines charming coastal vibes with gourmet cuisine, making it perfect for a serene baptism brunch or dinner.


  • Why it’s great: Waterfront views, fresh seafood, and flexible event spaces.

3. Windows on the Lake – Lake Ronkonkoma, NY


A favorite in Suffolk County, Windows on the Lake offers breathtaking lakefront views, customizable menus, and indoor/outdoor options. It’s particularly popular for milestone celebrations like baptisms, communions, and weddings.


  • Why it’s great: Scenic photo opportunities, all-seasons availability, and a kid friendly atmosphere.
A romantic proposal scene set between rows of grapevines in a scenic vineyard with white flowers and a blanket.

4. The Garden City Hotel – Garden City, NY


For those looking to host a luxurious event, The Garden City Hotel is a premier venue. Known for its refined service and upscale décor, it’s an excellent choice for a formal luncheon or elegant reception following the baptism ceremony.


Why it’s great: Central location, renowned cuisine, and timeless elegance.

5. Insignia Prime Steak & Sushi – Smithtown, NY


Looking for something modern and sophisticated? Insignia blends the style of a Manhattan lounge with the warmth of a family gathering space. Their private dining rooms are perfect for smaller, stylish baptism parties.


Why it’s great: Contemporary ambiance, excellent food, and private dining options.

Two people share a romantic moment on a wooden boardwalk pathway with a red and white lighthouse in the background.

6. Milleridge Inn – Jericho, NY


Charming and classic, the Milleridge Inn offers historic buildings, cozy rooms, and traditional American fare. It’s perfect for families seeking a relaxed and warm setting for their celebration.


Why it’s great: Family friendly charm, long standing reputation, and customizable menus.

Tips for Choosing the Right Venue:


Consider the size of your guest list — some venues specialize in intimate gatherings, while others are equipped for large parties.

Ask about religious accommodations, such as private prayer space or time-flexible bookings.

Think about the food — brunch buffets, plated dinners, or even afternoon tea can create very different atmospheres.

Location matters — pick a venue close to the church or chapel where the baptism will be held for guest convenience.

Long Island is home to many beautiful venues that can make your child’s baptism a joyful and memorable celebration. From elegant hotels to cozy inns and scenic waterfronts, there's a perfect place waiting to host your special day.


Looking for help planning your baptism party? Contact local event planners or reach out directly to these venues to start customizing your celebration.

Contact Me